Findings

What the 311 data shows

Finding 1

Communities where more residents don't speak English make far fewer infrastructure reports

We grouped communities into four equal groups by the share of residents with no knowledge of English (2021 Census), then counted reports about roads, sidewalks, streetlights, water, sewers, parks and trees per 1,000 residents. These include snow and ice, debris and park garbage requests. Counting only defects gives the same result.

Infrastructure reports per 1,000 residents per year

Part of that raw gap comes from other differences: older neighbourhoods have older pipes and sidewalks, and newer suburbs have fewer problems. Comparing communities first settled in the same era, the gap remains. Those groups still differ in income and location, which the estimate below accounts for.

Like for like: 63 communities first settled 1975–2000
Every way we measured it shows fewer reports

Estimated difference in infrastructure reports for a community where 5% of residents don't speak English versus 1%, under 14 different models. The darker dot is the main model, with its 95% range from a bootstrap that resamples whole areas.

−40%−20%0%
Best estimate: about 23% fewer reports (95% range 9% to 33%) after accounting for income, renters, community age and distance from downtown. The pattern holds outside northeast Calgary, for roads, water and parks separately, in each year studied, and when communities are linked to areas using the City's own community lists (about 20% fewer).

What about City inspections? The City finds some problems itself: potholes through routine inspections as well as 311 reports, and sidewalks through regular condition surveys. Others, like streetlights, reach the City mainly through residents' reports. The study measures who reports, not what gets fixed, and the gap is not limited to inspected assets: comparing the group with the most non-English speakers to the group with the fewest, reports are lower in 20 of the 21 request types (raw rates), including streetlights (23% lower), potholes (35%) and sidewalks (40%). The one exception is dead animal pick-up. Inspections may catch part of what goes unreported for roads and sidewalks; City inspection data could show how much.

One caution: communities with more non-English speakers also tend to have more visible-minority residents and recent newcomers. The data can't separate these, so this shows who 311 hears less from, not exactly why.

Finding 2

Once a request is made, the City closes it equally fast in every group

We compared each community's requests with the citywide speed for the same type of request in the same year. Across income groups and language groups, the share closed within 7 days is within 1.5% of expected, and within 0.6% at 30 days. Long waits of more than 90 days are rare (about 2% of requests) and vary more, from 93% to 107% of expected across income groups, with no consistent direction.

Speed index: requests closed within 7 days, compared with the citywide pace for the same requests (Calgary = 100)

One caution: "closed" in 311 records means the City closed the request, which doesn't always mean the problem was fixed.

Finding 3

A smaller share of requests come through the 311 app in lower-income and non-English-speaking areas

Share of all 311 requests made through the app

The City says it will add more languages to the 311 app in 2026. These communities are where that matters most.

Sources: 311 Service Requests · Calgary Equity Index, 2021 Census by community, Current Year Property Assessments, Building Permits, Historical Community Populations (City of Calgary open data) · 311 Calgary app · Related research: Kontokosta et al. (2017), New York City. Not affiliated with The City of Calgary.